COVID-19: Transfer prices and permanent establishments

Effects of COVID-19 on transfer prices and permanent establishments

Due to the outbreak of the corona virus, multinational companies are often confronted with an immediate change in the economic environment, e.g. due to supply chain disruptions or stagnating sales. As a result, actions are required concerning the implemented classical business models and the corresponding transfer pricing systems.

Effects on typical principal structures

Many multinational corporations have implemented a typical principal structure. Within the value chain, individual functions are outsourced, for example, to contract research and development companies, contract manufacturers, and routine distributors (so-called LRD). These companies perform routine functions and, therefore, are only exposed to minor risks or are (financially) relieved of risks by the transfer price system implemented. Therefore, the routine companies receive only a low but stable remuneration. The residual profit, i.e. the difference between the sales to third parties minus the remuneration of the routine companies, remains with the principal. As a result, the principal benefits from rising group profits, but has to bear the (financial) risks within the value chain. For the principal, this means that it generally must bear the financial losses suffered by the routine companies as a result of the corona crisis. For the principal, this leads to a considerable burden on the income as well as the cash flow statement. In order to prevent the principal from getting into financial difficulties himself as a result of the corona crisis, possible adjustments of the prices and margins applied should, therefore, be examined.

There are various possibilities for (transfer) price or margin adjustments. Generally, an adjustment of the (transfer) prices and margins within the arm’s length range determined by benchmark studies can be made first. In addition, it is conceivable to make new benchmark studies in the near future and thereby determine a range that was achieved by routine companies in comparable recession periods. In order to ensure tax recognition, prompt action, and appropriate documentation is required.

Intra-group financing services

The liquidity needs of many companies triggered by the corona crisis cannot only be met by bank financing but also by intra-group loans. In this context, the interest rate applied must comply with the arm’s length principle, which avoids tax add-backs for the lender on the one hand and the borrower on the other. In Switzerland, the minimum and maximum interest rates stipulated by the FTA should be taken into account, unless a different interest rate can be proven by a third-party comparison (usually by a benchmark study). The support measures of the government and the corresponding interest rates applied can be taken into account as third-party prices as well.

The borrower must also ensure that the interest payments resulting from the debt financing can be claimed as expenses for tax purposes and that there are no restrictions on the deduction of interest.

Tax treatment of home office

In times of the corona virus many employees work from home. Particularly in areas close to the border (but also in inter-cantonal relations), the question arises whether the home office constitutes a permanent establishment. If this is the case, a corresponding tax assessment would have to be made.

The FTA has already commented on this issue. It has come to the conclusion that from today's perspective, an "enforced" home office is not geared towards permanent activity and, for this reason alone, does not constitute a permanent establishment. However, if the activity in the home office should last for a period of more than six months, the situation must be examined on an individual case by case basis. In most cases, however, even in the case of longer-term arrangements, the employer's power of disposal over the home office premises and the exclusive business use will be missing in order to qualify as a permanent establishment.

April 2020 | Authors: Thomas Linder, Dr. Hagen Luckhaupt, Simone Camenisch

Your team

Contact

In need of legal, tax or compliance advice? We look forward to contacting you.

From the magazine

Simplified Procedure Short-Time Work

Many companies have to renew their applications for short-time work. The Federal Council has again decided to extend several simplifications.

Coronavirus from employment law perspective

The numbers of new corona infections are during the second wave still very high – even though the trend has been slightly going towards falling numbers again. The pandemic should, however, be taken as an opportunity for employees and employers alike to remember their rights and obligations. The impact of the coronavirus on public life is far greater than the one of past pandemic-like situations. It is impossible to predict with certainty how labour courts will judge various issues which may arise from this pandemic. But Swiss labour law already offers many answers. You will find the most important ones in this magazine article.

Planning and building law in the Corona crisis

Federal Council issued on 16 March 2020. Despite the move to home offices and the consequent reduction in the range of services offered by cantonal and communal authorities, the authorities are committed to maintaining the planning and building permit procedures in line with the measures ordered to combat the corona virus. As the supervisory authority, the Building Department of the Canton of Zurich issued a circular letter to the communes on 26 March 2020. The following discussion is intended to provide information on how the procedures in building and planning law will continue in the Corona crisis. The information is limited to the Canton of Zurich, although communal differences may arise.

Work and childcare

In March 2020, all schools and kindergartens in Switzerland have been closed for eight weeks. A further school closure is not unlikely. In that case, hundreds of thousands of children would have to stay at home again. But who pays the wages of the employees if they have to look after their children at home? In our FAQ we try to give you an overview of the most frequent questions.

Insurance coverage of epidemics and pandemics

The explosive spread of the corona virus and the resulting official restrictions on business life have led to large and potentially existential financial losses for companies and the self-employed. It is advisable to check whether there is insurance cover for the damages suffered.

Tax Relief

In order to cushion the economic impacts of the spread of the coronavirus, the Federal Council decided, among other things, to provide liquidity aid in tax matters.

Home Office

By minimising social contacts through the adoption of appropriate measures, the authorities are currently trying to slow down the spread of Covid-19. This also has deep effects on professional life. The instruction to work from home ("home office") is an effective means to achieve this, however there are challenges to overcome.

Force Majeure in Contract Law

In this article, the question is discussed how contractual defaults caused by the coronavirus are to be legally assessed and what can be legally applied.

Liquidity shortage

As a result of the Swiss federal governmental measures against the coronavirus, many companies in Switzerland find themselves in a liquidity shortage. The Swiss debt enforcement and bankruptcy law contains provisions which protect the debtor’s interest. This gives the debtor time to eliminaLte the liquidity shortage.

Current Pandemic and Official Orders

The economic impact of coronavirus is immense for Swiss companies and their employees. We are happy to provide advice and assistance on legal and tax issues relating to the current pandemic and the orders of the authorities.

FAQ Coronavirus & Employment Law

The coronavirus is spreading rapidly. Except in China, human infection has been confirmed in almost 30 countries. This also poses great challenges and raises questions for employers and employees.

All magazine reports

Publications

  • Dr. Peter Brülisauer

    Transfer Pricing bei komplexen Geschäftsmodellen / Erfahrungen aus der Praxis

    PDF

  • Dr. Peter Brülisauer

    Gewinnermittlung im Lichte von Art. 25b StHG

    PDF

All publications